Leftover Thoughts

What risks should make me delay retirement?

I'm a ways out from retirement, but old enough that I better be planning for it. I'm posting here about the parts that are requiring some thought.

One approach to retirement planning is to work until you've eliminated all risk. This is known as the involuntary retirement approach: You work until working is no longer an option, whether for health reasons or because you lost your job/clients/customers. Since there is no way to eliminate all risk, voluntary retirement is impossible.

For the rest of us, those of us who have been saving what we can and want voluntary retirement, a decision needs to be made about which risks we'll live with and which we won't. Some examples of risks that won't influence my retirement decision:

All of the above cases are intentionally chosen because they are low-probability events that cannot be solved by working longer or pursuing a particular strategy. If our current system of property rights disappears, and the government confiscates my stock portfolio, I'll deal with that when it happens. I don't think it's controversial to say anyone planning for retirement should assume things like stocks having reasonable value, personal wealth will not be confiscated, and you won't be the world's oldest living person.

Other risks should obviously be considered by anyone:

This group should not be controversial either. There's no reason to think 30% stock market declines won't happen, and large maintenance expenditures are a given when you own a house.

Where this gets tough is the stuff that falls between these extremes. Should you plan for inflation like we had from the late 1960s to the early 1980s? It's extremely common to do so. I'm skeptical that we'll ever see a repeat of that (if you doubt that, look at the 2026 election outcome when inflation was modest compared to the 1970s). On the other hand, we almost saw double-digit inflation for a brief period in the aftermath of the pandemic. Does it really matter? It does if you want to set yourself up to survive multiple years of 10%+ inflation, as opposed to an average of 3%. You might need to work an extra five years to be comfortable that your plan would have survived the 1970s.

It's especially difficult when you consider the uncertainty around medical expenditures, how long you'll have energy to spend money, or the deterioration of your cognitive abilities. When we retire, my spouse might be bored and spend a bunch of money, or I might enjoy low-cost hobbies and decide I should have retired a decade earlier. How can you know that?

This uncertainty is perhaps the hardest part of retirement planning. Retirement planners cannot help you with these decisions. They'll run the Monte Carlo simulations, but that only tells you how you'd have done in prior years, when you're planning for the future. They'll tell you to look at your current spending, but what you spend at 60 is going to be very different from what you spend at 80. Adjusting current spending for an assumed inflation rate should not give you confidence that you know whether or not you're ready to retire.

This gets easier if you're willing to optimize to protect yourself against retiring too early. I'm not willing to do that, nor do I think most people should. If you've got $500k in a retirement account plus Social Security, you're not going to find yourself homeless at 85. By all means, protect yourself against homelessness at 85. The reality is that if you're someone with $500k in a 401k, a mortgage-free house, and a solid plan, but you work an extra five years for the heck of it, you haven't added any security to your retirement. The extra five years doesn't prevent homelessness and it might pay for a little extra travel. On the other hand, five years of additional retirement might be the last five healthy years you can spend with your spouse. One could argue that the optimization should be tilted against retiring too late rather than against retiring too early.

Do I have a solution? No, and the only solution I see is to live with the risk that any successful retirement plan has limitations. It's about taking sensible risks, and right now I'm not sure what's a sensible risk for me.